Pilot Review: Elementary

I’ve never read any of the Sherlock Holmes stories by Arthur Conan Doyle (but that didn’t stop me from writing a book report on one of them in junior high) and therefore am not an expert on the character. I am a very, very big fan of the BBC series Sherlock, a contemporary take on the detective that stars Benedict Cumberbatch as Holmes and Martin Freeman as Watson. I didn’t care for Guy Ritchie’s Sherlock Holmes starring Robert Downey Jr. and Jude Law, but I did enjoy its sequel A Game of Shadows.

Continue Reading

Pilot Review: Made in Jersey

This is going to be short.

CBS’s Made in Jersey is a new legal drama starring the British-born Janet Montgomery as Martina Garretti, a young lawyer who was raised in – you guessed it – New Jersey, and is working at some fancy law firm in New York. As the series makes abundantly clear in the pilot, Martina’s background and upbringing is instrumental in helping her defend clients, though it doesn’t exactly make her popular with some of her more discriminating colleagues. at work

As I expected, Made in Jersey fits the mold of every other CBS procedural. Where it tries to differentiate itself isn’t in the case of the week formula (which is as dull as ever), but with Martina, who looks and sounds like your stereotypical Italian-American Jersey girl but is obviously smarter than those stereotypes would have you believe. As for how certain viewers will react to the depiction of Martina’s family, I really don’t care. For a first episode there really isn’t any time to get to know any of them, so all we have are the broad strokes.

The show’s main draw (really, only draw) is the beautiful Montgomery, who’s a strong presence onscreen and gives a charismatic performance as Martina. Her Jersey accent sounds convincing enough (though I’m no expert), and I couldn’t detect any instance where her natural English accent revealed itself. I’ve liked Montgomery since I first saw her in FOX’s action series Human Target (though her character was a superfluous addition to the cast), and if I do continue to watch Made in Jersey, it’ll be for her.

Pilot Review: Last Resort

There’s still a lot of new fall TV premiering in the next few weeks, but I don’t need to have seen them to know that ABC’s Last Resort, which premieres tonight, is one of the most intriguing, if not the most intriguing new show of the season. Set aboard the fictional USS Colorado submarine, the series follows the exploits of the submarine’s crew when, after questioning orders to fire nuclear weapons upon Pakistan (orders that were not relayed through official channels), another Navy sub attempts to sink it. Unable to surface without the possibility of being attacked again, the sub’s captain, Marcus Chaplin (played by Andre Braugher) plots a course for an island that will serve as a safe haven while he and his crew try to figure out why they were fired upon and who ordered them to fire on Pakistan. Continue Reading

Pilot Review: The Mindy Project

Warning: this post contains many uses of the name Mindy.

The Mindy of The Mindy Project, who is played by series creator Mindy Kaling (of The Office fame), is what I imagine Kelly Kapoor would be like if she wasn’t such a moron. Both of them are pretty obsessed with their love lives and are well-versed in pop culture. The difference is that Kelly is a full-blown narcissist and Mindy (the character), while clearly self-involved, isn’t as bad. Her being an obstetrician helps establish her as someone who (at least occasionally) thinks about others. At the start of the pilot, the wedding of an ex-boyfriend sends Mindy on a drunken spiral that lands her in jail. From there on out she vows to take life more seriously, look for the right guy, advance her career, etc. There’s other people around too, like work colleagues Dr. Asshole (Chris Messina) and Dr. British Womanizer (Ed Weeks) and best friend Gwen (Anna Camp), but as the title suggests, The Mindy Project is all about Mindy. Continue Reading

Pilot Review: Ben and Kate

As Kate (Dakota Johnson) explains in the opening voiceover, she and her older brother Ben (Oscar-winning screenwriter Nat Faxon) are products of a broken home. She got pregnant very young and was forced to become an adult much sooner than expected, while Ben’s lack of responsibilities have kept him stuck in “man-child” mode. Being a single parent is a full time job, meaning all other aspects of Kate’s life have been permanently put on hold, and Ben constantly dropping by unannounced to cause trouble isn’t helping matters. Continue Reading

Pilot Review: Revolution (and some blog stuff)

It’s that time of the year again. Summer may be over, and Winter is coming (ha ha), but it’s Christmas time for TV lovers. We have a whole month and a half of returning shows to look forward to, along with the premieres of a bunch of new ones.

Last season I did my best to watch and write at least a little about most of the new fall shows that premiered. It took quite a bit of time, and it also resulted in me watching a bunch of not so good shows that I probably wouldn’t have bothered watching had it not been for the blog. So rather than go through that again, this month I’m only gonna be watching and writing about the shows that I’m actually interested in seeing, and skipping over the ones that don’t appeal to me (like The New Normal and Guys with Kids, for example). So hopefully you can look forward to pilot reviews of The Mindy Project, Vegas, Last Resort (which I’ve already seen and am pretty intrigued by), Elementary, Made in Jersey, 666 Park Avenue, and later on in October: Arrow, Beauty and the Beast, and Nashville. Today, I’ve got some thoughts on the pilot of the new sci-fi show Revolution, premiering tomorrow night on NBC (very minor spoilers ahead). Continue Reading